Bug 251137

Summary:

Safari 16 throws error on encrypted video

Product:

WebKit

Reporter:

Vitaly <vitaly.ivanov>

Component:

New Bugs

Assignee:

Nobody <webkit-unassigned>

Status:

NEW ---

Severity:

Normal

CC:

eric.carlson, jer.noble, webkit-bug-importer

Priority:

Keywords:

InRadar

Version:

Safari 16

Hardware:

Mac (Apple Silicon)

OS:

macOS 13

Attachments:

Description	Flags
HTML/JS and media to deploy locally	none

Description Vitaly 2023-01-24 22:05:59 PST

Created attachment 464644 [details]
HTML/JS and media to deploy locally

Certain videos encoded with Intel QSV in CBR mode and encrypted with CBCS 1:9 cause Safari 16.2 (both regular and TP) on macOS 13.1 on M1 Air to throw an error after a few seconds of playback.
I've used both my own encryptor and Shaka Packager - the result is the same. At the same time there are no errors on my old Intel-based MBP (mid 2012) / macOS 10.15.7 / Safari 15.6 as well as on iPad Air 2 / iPadOS 15.5, which leads me to believe the faulty link is Safari 16, maybe in combination with Apple silicon.

The demo is deployed here (it's pretty much Apple's own FairPlay sample code with castLabs DRMtoday license acquisition):
http://pop-av.icu:8898/

Comment 1 Vitaly 2023-01-24 22:22:39 PST

It's also worth mentioning it works perfectly fine with third-party decryptors/players: Chrome on any platform/hardware via MSE with ClearKey or Widevine or PlayReady, ffplay (ffplay -decryption_key 3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c3c out-2-encr.mp4, but not with the stable 5.1.2 as it has couple of bugs around 'trun' parsing which are fixed in main), etc

Comment 2 Radar WebKit Bug Importer 2023-01-25 17:17:21 PST

<rdar://problem/104674800>

Comment 3 Vitaly 2023-01-25 18:25:53 PST

Moved the demo to https://vitaly-castlabs.github.io/safari16-decr-issue

Comment 4 Vitaly 2023-05-10 22:45:46 PDT

ffmpeg Stable has been updated to 6.0 since, so "ffplay -decryption_key..." now works fine too

Comment 5 Vitaly 2023-07-12 23:53:51 PDT

Verbose MSE log:
[Debug] SourceBuffer::monitorBufferingRate(9FFAD41A0090001) 0.2638390404863951
[Debug] SourceBuffer::sourceBufferPrivateAppendComplete(9FFAD41A0090001) buffered = [{0/1 = 0}..{1477/1000 = 1.477}] 
[Debug] SourceBuffer::appendBufferInternal(9FFAD41A0090001) size = 19836, buffered = [{0/1 = 0}..{1477/1000 = 1.477}] 
[Debug] SourceBuffer::monitorBufferingRate(9FFAD41A0090001) 0.2649563195125863
[Debug] SourceBuffer::sourceBufferPrivateAppendComplete(9FFAD41A0090001) buffered = [{0/1 = 0}..{1495/1000 = 1.495}] 
[Error] SourceBuffer::sourceBufferPrivateDidReceiveRenderingError(9FFAD41A0090001) 0
[Log] MediaSource::streamEndedWithError(9FFAD41A0098DE6) decode
[Log] MediaSource::onReadyStateChange(9FFAD41A0098DE6) old state = open, new state = ended
[Debug] MediaSource::scheduleEvent(9FFAD41A0098DE6) scheduling 'sourceended'
[Log] MediaSource::detachFromElement(9FFAD41A0098DE6) 
[Log] MediaSource::onReadyStateChange(9FFAD41A0098DE6) old state = ended, new state = closed
[Debug] MediaSource::scheduleEvent(9FFAD41A0098DE6) scheduling 'sourceclose'
[Debug] MediaSource::removeSourceBuffer(9FFAD41A0098DE6) 
[Error] SourceBuffer::sourceBufferPrivateDidReceiveRenderingError(9FFAD41A0090001) 0