Bug 223326

Summary: webgl/1.0.x/conformance/textures/misc/exif-orientation.html fails
Product: WebKit Reporter: Kimmo Kinnunen <kkinnunen>
Component: WebGLAssignee: Nobody <webkit-unassigned>
Status: RESOLVED FIXED    
Severity: Normal CC: dcasorran, dino, kbr, kkinnunen, micah.millereshleman, webkit-bug-importer
Priority: P2 Keywords: InRadar
Version: Other   
Hardware: Unspecified   
OS: Unspecified   
See Also: https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=242169
Bug Depends on:    
Bug Blocks: 222812    

Kimmo Kinnunen
Reported 2021-03-16 23:40:25 PDT
webgl/1.0.4/conformance/textures/misc/exif-orientation.html fails
Attachments
Kimmo Kinnunen
Comment 1 2021-03-17 00:30:56 PDT
*** Bug 223342 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
Kimmo Kinnunen
Comment 2 2021-03-17 01:17:01 PDT
https://www.khronos.org/registry/webgl/sdk/tests/conformance/textures/misc/exif-orientation.html?webglVersion=1&quiet=0&quick=1 Verifies EXIF orientation is respected when uploading images to WebGL textures On success, you will see a series of "PASS" messages, followed by "TEST COMPLETE". ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-1-normal.jpg via ImageBitmap from Blob (createImageBitmap options not supported - skipping flipY=true case) Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-1-normal.jpg via HTMLImageElement Testing texImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-2-mirror-horizontal.jpg via ImageBitmap from Blob (createImageBitmap options not supported - skipping flipY=true case) Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left FAIL shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 at (102, 128) expected: 0,0,255 was 255,255,1 Checking right FAIL shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 at (153, 128) expected: 255,255,0 was 0,0,254 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left FAIL shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 at (102, 128) expected: 0,0,255 was 255,255,1 Checking right FAIL shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 at (153, 128) expected: 255,255,0 was 0,0,254 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-2-mirror-horizontal.jpg via HTMLImageElement Testing texImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-3-rotate-180.jpg via ImageBitmap from Blob (createImageBitmap options not supported - skipping flipY=true case) Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top FAIL shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 at (128, 64) expected: 255,0,0 was 0,255,1 Checking left FAIL shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 at (102, 128) expected: 0,0,255 was 255,255,1 Checking right FAIL shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 at (153, 128) expected: 255,255,0 was 0,0,254 Checking bottom FAIL shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 at (128, 192) expected: 0,255,0 was 254,0,0 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top FAIL shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 at (128, 64) expected: 255,0,0 was 0,255,1 Checking left FAIL shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 at (102, 128) expected: 0,0,255 was 255,255,1 Checking right FAIL shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 at (153, 128) expected: 255,255,0 was 0,0,254 Checking bottom FAIL shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 at (128, 192) expected: 0,255,0 was 254,0,0 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-3-rotate-180.jpg via HTMLImageElement Testing texImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-4-mirror-vertical.jpg via ImageBitmap from Blob (createImageBitmap options not supported - skipping flipY=true case) Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top FAIL shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 at (128, 64) expected: 255,0,0 was 0,255,1 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom FAIL shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 at (128, 192) expected: 0,255,0 was 254,0,0 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top FAIL shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 at (128, 64) expected: 255,0,0 was 0,255,1 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom FAIL shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 at (128, 192) expected: 0,255,0 was 254,0,0 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-4-mirror-vertical.jpg via HTMLImageElement Testing texImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-5-mirror-horizontal-90-ccw.jpg via ImageBitmap from Blob (createImageBitmap options not supported - skipping flipY=true case) Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top FAIL shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 at (128, 64) expected: 255,0,0 was 0,0,254 Checking left FAIL shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 at (102, 128) expected: 0,0,255 was 255,255,1 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom FAIL shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 at (128, 192) expected: 0,255,0 was 255,255,0 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top FAIL shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 at (128, 64) expected: 255,0,0 was 0,0,254 Checking left FAIL shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 at (102, 128) expected: 0,0,255 was 255,255,1 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom FAIL shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 at (128, 192) expected: 0,255,0 was 255,255,0 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-5-mirror-horizontal-90-ccw.jpg via HTMLImageElement Testing texImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-6-90-ccw.jpg via ImageBitmap from Blob (createImageBitmap options not supported - skipping flipY=true case) Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top FAIL shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 at (128, 64) expected: 255,0,0 was 255,255,1 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right FAIL shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 at (153, 128) expected: 255,255,0 was 0,0,254 Checking bottom FAIL shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 at (128, 192) expected: 0,255,0 was 0,0,254 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top FAIL shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 at (128, 64) expected: 255,0,0 was 255,255,1 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right FAIL shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 at (153, 128) expected: 255,255,0 was 0,0,254 Checking bottom FAIL shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 at (128, 192) expected: 0,255,0 was 0,0,254 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-6-90-ccw.jpg via HTMLImageElement Testing texImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-7-mirror-horizontal-90-cw.jpg via ImageBitmap from Blob (createImageBitmap options not supported - skipping flipY=true case) Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top FAIL shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 at (128, 64) expected: 255,0,0 was 255,255,1 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right FAIL shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 at (153, 128) expected: 255,255,0 was 0,0,254 Checking bottom FAIL shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 at (128, 192) expected: 0,255,0 was 0,0,254 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top FAIL shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 at (128, 64) expected: 255,0,0 was 255,255,1 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right FAIL shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 at (153, 128) expected: 255,255,0 was 0,0,254 Checking bottom FAIL shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 at (128, 192) expected: 0,255,0 was 0,0,254 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-7-mirror-horizontal-90-cw.jpg via HTMLImageElement Testing texImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-8-90-cw.jpg via ImageBitmap from Blob (createImageBitmap options not supported - skipping flipY=true case) Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top FAIL shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 at (128, 64) expected: 255,0,0 was 0,0,254 Checking left FAIL shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 at (102, 128) expected: 0,0,255 was 255,255,1 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom FAIL shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 at (128, 192) expected: 0,255,0 was 255,255,0 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top FAIL shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 at (128, 64) expected: 255,0,0 was 0,0,254 Checking left FAIL shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 at (102, 128) expected: 0,0,255 was 255,255,1 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom FAIL shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 at (128, 192) expected: 0,255,0 was 255,255,0 ---------------------------------------------------------------- Testing exif-orientation-test-8-90-cw.jpg via HTMLImageElement Testing texImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = true Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 Testing texSubImage2D, flipY = false Checking top PASS shouldBe 255,0,0 +/-5 Checking left PASS shouldBe 0,0,255 +/-5 Checking right PASS shouldBe 255,255,0 +/-5 Checking bottom PASS shouldBe 0,255,0 +/-5 PASS successfullyParsed is true TEST COMPLETE
Kimmo Kinnunen
Comment 3 2021-03-17 01:45:40 PDT
At least macOS 11.3, iMacPro1,1, Radeon Pro Vega 56
Radar WebKit Bug Importer
Comment 4 2021-03-23 23:41:11 PDT
Kimmo Kinnunen
Comment 5 2021-08-10 02:54:45 PDT
*** Bug 228948 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
Kimmo Kinnunen
Comment 6 2022-06-29 23:35:38 PDT
Kimmo Kinnunen
Comment 7 2022-06-29 23:51:59 PDT
*** Bug 242137 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
EWS
Comment 8 2022-08-01 13:06:57 PDT
Committed 253004@main (8758b1b9f855): <https://commits.webkit.org/253004@main> Reviewed commits have been landed. Closing PR #1897 and removing active labels.
Note You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.